Identity, Memory and Resistance: The Story of Khadeja, a Hazara Woman from Afghanistan
There are moments when a conversation reveals more than the words being exchanged. Sometimes, a person’s reaction, a hesitation or an unexpected question can open a window into experiences that are not immediately visible. I met Khadeja during a Dutch language course (TaalWeek) in the Netherlands. At first, she was simply another participant in the classroom, a Muslim woman wearing a hijab. We began talking, and as our conversation developed, I learned that she was from Afghanistan.
We sat together during a time break and as she spoke about her background, I told her, almost instinctively, “And you are from the Hazara people.” She looked surprised. Perhaps there was also a degree of apprehension in her reaction. She asked me, “And how do you know?” The truth was that I did not actually know. I had no particular information about her family or background. Rather, something in the way she spoke and approached the subject made me wonder whether she was hesitant to reveal her ethnic identity. I could not be certain, but I recognized something in that hesitation.
I knew that feeling because I had experienced something similar myself.
As a member of the Yazidi community, there have been circumstances in which I preferred to keep my religious identity undisclosed. Not because I was ashamed of who I was, but because revealing it could invite questions, assumptions, misunderstandings or unwanted attention concerning my beliefs and background. Sometimes, remaining silent about one’s identity becomes a way of avoiding the burden of having to explain oneself to others.
Perhaps this was why I was particularly attentive to her reaction. I did not know whether Khadeja had similar experiences or whether my interpretation was correct. Nevertheless, that brief exchange made me reflect on something familiar: the circumstances in which people feel that revealing who they are requires a certain degree of courage.
As we became more acquainted, our conversation developed into a discussion about her life in Afghanistan, her Hazara identity, her religious beliefs and the difficulties faced by women and minorities under Taliban authority.
After getting to know each other, Khadeja agreed to be interviewed and to allow me to write about her story. Thus, What began as an ordinary encounter in a language classroom gradually became an opportunity to explore a subject that had interested me for years.
From the pages of a novel to a human encounter
My interest in the Hazara community began long before I met Khadeja. I first encountered the subject through The Kite Runner, the novel by Afghan-American author Khaled Hosseini. Although literature was my initial introduction to the Hazara people, it encouraged me to look beyond the narrative of a novel and explore their historical background, cultural identity and the persecution they have experienced throughout generations.
The more I read, the more overwhelmed I became by the history of a community that has repeatedly faced discrimination and violence because of its ethnic identity, which mad me began asking questions that have long occupied my thoughts: Why does belonging to a particular ethnic or religious community become a reason for persecution? Why should someone’s beliefs, cultural heritage or ancestry determine the extent to which they are allowed to live freely?
Perhaps my own background as a Yazidi has made these questions particularly close to me. My community has experienced centuries of persecution, with the genocide committed by ISIS in 2014 representing one of the most devastating chapters in its history.
The histories of Hazaras and Yazidis are distinct, shaped by different political, religious and historical circumstances. Nevertheless, there are painful points of resonance in the experiences of communities whose identities have become grounds for discrimination, exclusion and violence.
This connection has influenced the way I approach the subject. I do not see the persecution of minorities merely as a historical or political phenomenon to be studied from a distance. I also recognise the human consequences of being judged, marginalised or threatened because of who one is.
Meeting Khadeja brought this interest into a different context. What I had previously encountered through literature and historical research was now represented by a person sitting beside me in a Dutch language classroom.
Being Hazara: Identity, religion and belonging
The Hazaras are one of Afghanistan’s historically marginalised ethnic communities, with a significant population concentrated in the central highlands, particularly the region known as Hazarajat. The majority of Hazaras identify with Twelver Shia Islam, although the community also includes Sunni and Ismaili Muslims.
For Shia Muslims, Imam Ali occupies a central position in religious and spiritual thought, as his legacy is associated with principles of justice, dignity and moral responsibility.
During our conversation, Khadeja expressed pride in being Hazara and in following the teachings of Imam Ali. Despite the history of discrimination against her community, she did not speak about her identity as something to conceal or abandon. Rather, she regarded it as an important part of who she was.
There is something significant about this distinction. An identity can become a target of discrimination, but it can also remain a source of dignity, belonging and personal conviction. Hazara people, however, throughout Afghanistan’s history, has experienced ethnic discrimination, political marginalisation, forced displacement and episodes of mass violence. Their persecution has occurred under different political authorities and cannot be attributed to a single period or regime. In more recent decades, they have also been targeted by extremist groups because of their ethnic and religious identity. The Taliban’s return to power in August 2021 intensified concerns about the security and rights of religious and ethnic minorities, including Hazaras.
A woman, a teacher and the question of freedom
One of the most significant aspects of Khadeja’s story is her former profession. She was a schoolteacher in Afghanistan. “Education is more than the transmission of knowledge, it is also a means through which individuals develop independence, critical thinking and the ability to participate in society.” She said, then she added “But we were not allowed to think for ourselves or to develop”. For women in particular, access to education can influence their opportunities, autonomy and position within their communities.
During our conversation, Khadeja explained that she had never felt safe in Afghanistan because of the patriarchal structures within society and the authority exercised by the Taliban. Her account brought to mind a broader question: What happens to a society when women are denied the opportunity to determine their own lives?
Since returning to power in August 2021, the Taliban authorities have imposed extensive restrictions on Afghan women’s and girls’ rights. Girls have been prevented from attending secondary education, women have been excluded from universities, and restrictions have also affected employment, movement and participation in public life.
Khadeja’s experience as a former teacher gives this issue a particularly human dimension. She is not discussing education as an abstract political subject. She has worked in a classroom and understands what it means to have a professional identity within a society where women’s opportunities and freedoms are restricted.
Her story raises a question that deserves greater attention: How many women have had their professional ambitions, intellectual development and personal aspirations interrupted by political and ideological systems that seek to control their lives?
Khadeja now lives in the Netherlands, where she is involved in advocacy and awareness activities concerning her community and, particularly, the situation of Afghan women under Taliban authority. I understood her efforts to speak publicly about these issues as an attempt to make visible the experiences of people whose circumstances prevent them from expressing themselves freely.
I found this particularly significant. Living in a society where freedom of expression is protected can provide opportunities to speak about experiences that might otherwise remain unheard. Yet having the opportunity to speak does not mean that the suffering of those who remain behind has ended.
For Khadeja, raising awareness about the situation of Hazara people and Afghan women is a way of contributing to a wider conversation about human rights, discrimination and freedom.
The responsibility of remembering and speaking
As someone from the Yazidi community, I cannot approach the subject of minority persecution without reflecting on the experiences of my own people. The Yazidis have endured centuries of persecution, with the genocide committed by ISIS in 2014 representing one of the most devastating chapters in their history. Their religious identity became a justification for violence, displacement, enslavement and the destruction of families and communities. I do not suggest that the histories of Hazaras and Yazidis are identical. Each community has its own historical experiences, religious traditions, political circumstances and forms of persecution.
Nevertheless, both histories remind us of the devastating consequences of allowing ideological extremism and religious intolerance to determine who deserves to live with dignity and freedom.
For me, this connection makes the importance of solidarity particularly evident which requires recognising the dignity of others and understanding that the freedom of one community should never come at the expense of another.
Meeting Khadeja brought a subject I had previously explored through literature and historical research into a human context.
I began with an interest in understanding the Hazara community and its history. I found myself listening to a woman who was proud of her identity, who had worked as a teacher in Afghanistan and who now participates in raising awareness about the challenges faced by her community.
Our conversation reminded me that behind historical accounts of persecution are individuals with their own ambitions, convictions, memories and aspirations, who are not merely representatives of ethnic or religious groups, but are people who want to work, study, raise families, express their beliefs and participate in society without fearing discrimination or persecution. Perhaps the most fundamental question is also the simplest: Why should anyone have to justify their right to exist, to believe, to belong or to speak? The right to be who we are should not be a privilege granted by political authorities or determined by the dominant ideology of a society which is a fundamental human right.
Perhaps this is why that brief exchange in the language classroom has remained with me. When I told Khadeja that I thought she was Hazara, I was not certain of her identity, but rather I was responding to an impression, shaped partly by my own experiences of belonging to a minority whose identity has not always been easy to disclose.
Her question, “And how do you know?”, made me reflect on the circumstances in which identity becomes something people hesitate to reveal.
I do not know whether she experienced that moment in the same way I did. But it reminded me that the freedom to identify oneself openly is something that should never be taken for granted. Some stories begin in books, and others begin in classrooms. But the stories that deserve to be remembered are those that remind us of our shared humanity and our responsibility not to remain indifferent when the rights and dignity of others are threatened.
Ultimately, the right to be who we are should never be something we have to ask permission for.


